- SpaceX listed on Wall Street at an 11% premium
- Former assistant to Peter Lynch criticised SpaceX's valuation
- Lynch avoided hype stocks, favoring undervalued firms with proven financials
SpaceX has entered Wall Street in a groundbreaking way to list at an 11% premium, boosting the firm's market capitalisation to over $2 trillion. However, a former assistant to legendary investor Peter Lynch has argued that the investor would have avoided the IPO altogether.
George Noble, who worked with Lynch in the 1980s, said SpaceX represents the kind of "hot story" stock that Lynch typically stayed away from — companies driven by charismatic founders, massive promises and future possibilities rather than proven financial performance.
"Peter would have looked at this and bought Kellogg's instead. He would have laughed at the idea of paying $1.77 trillion for a company that loses money everywhere except one segment," Noble said in a post on X.
Lynch's approach was built around finding undervalued businesses before Wall Street discovered them, rather than buying companies after they became market favourites.
He argued that Lynch would have questioned whether SpaceX can realistically deliver on all these opportunities simultaneously.
ALSO READ: 50% Crash On Cards? Why Morningstar Believes SpaceX Is Worth Only $63 Post IPO
"Peter built his career getting into stocks BEFORE the institutions arrived. He believed your edge came from being early. SpaceX is the opposite - every passive index fund in America is about to be forced to buy this thing at $1.77 trillion whether they want to or not. The smart money is NOT buying SpaceX today. You shouldn't either," his post stated.
The key challenges include making Starship commercially viable at scale, maintaining Starlink's profitability as competition in satellite internet increases, competing in AI infrastructure, and eventually generating returns from space exploration ambitions, he highlighted.
Noble pointed to the company's financial profile as a concern, arguing that much of the company's valuation depends on future success rather than current profitability. While Starlink has emerged as SpaceX's main revenue-generating business, other projects require significant investment and remain uncertain.
The criticism came as SpaceX's IPO attracted enormous investor interest. The offering was heavily oversubscribed, with strong participation from institutions and retail investors betting on the company's long-term vision.
For SpaceX bulls, the company's valuation reflects the possibility of becoming a dominant force in space, connectivity and AI infrastructure. But according to Lynch's former assistant, the legendary investor would have focused less on the dream and more on whether the current numbers justify the price.
Essential Business Intelligence, Continuous LIVE TV, Sharp Market Insights, Practical Personal Finance Advice and Latest Stories — On NDTV Profit.
