Planning Commission Deputy Chairman Montek Singh Ahluwalia on Monday termed the decision to allot Talabira-II coal mine to Hindalco by Prime Minister Manmohan Singh as "absolutely right" and said investigating agencies need to develop a "civilised approach" to the business of investigation.
"What the Prime Minister has said is that the issue came up, the reasons for changing the decision was absolutely right and there has been too much focus in the press just on the fact that there was a change. There is nothing wrong with changing the decision in the light of new facts," he said on a private news channel on Monday.
He was replying to a volley of questions on clarification issued by the Prime Minister's Office (PMO) on Saturday in connection with a CBI FIR, which named Aditya Birla group chief Kumar Mangalam Birla and former Coal Secretary P C Parakh in the 'coalgate' scam.
Also Read | Layoffs Are Rising In Tech, But These Skills Are Helping People Unlock Better Pay
The agency in its FIR has alleged that "competent authority" favoured Hindalco and changed the earlier decision to allocate Talabira-II coal mine in Odisha to PSU Neyveli Lignite. Mr Ahluwalia said investigations should be conducted in such a way as not to harm reputation of anyone and the person should be treated as innocent till proven guilty.
(Also read: Satisfied with coal block allocations: PM)
"We need a system where if investigating agencies want to investigate, there must be a way in which they can do that without damage to reputation, without the presumption of innocent until proved guilty is being washed away in some way... We need to develop a civilised approach to the whole business of investigation," he said.
"The industry should take note of the fact that Mr Birla is now in a position to say that if the facts on the file are right, there is nothing wrong in the decision which is actually not against anybody. It was not something taken away from the public sector and given to Hindalco."
To a question on why the Prime Minister's Office (PMO) took three days after the CBI FIR to clarify its position, Mr Ahluwalia said, "They (CBI) are not under the control of the government. But three days is a remarkably short time to clarify anything."
He further said that "if the CBI has other information, which leads to a different conclusion, that is a separate matter".
Noting that a reference was made by the PMO to the Coal Ministry to take note of the representation made by Mr Birla on behalf of Hindalco, Mr Ahluwalia said this changed an earlier decision and so "more attention to normal" would have been given by officials before putting up the file for the PM's approval.
When asked why Prime Minister was not considered part of the conspiracy, when FIR was registered against former Coal Secretary Mr Parakh and Mr Birla for the same, Mr Ahluwalia said the question was hypothetical.
"Whether there was a conspiracy at certain level or not is a separate issue CBI will look into it. What is correct is if the facts are as recorded on the files, the Prime Minister backed Parakh's decision. That is absolutely clear," he said.
Defending the PMO, the Planning Commission Deputy Chairman said that they cannot check if the facts get doctored before reaching them and it is for the CBI to determine.
At the same time, "any damage to the reputation of both, of a civil servant and of Mr Birla is highly regrettable" and a "civilised approach" is required to do the investigations, he said.
Trying to calm the nerves of India Inc, Mr Ahluwalia said that the government is very much aware that an efficient, dynamic country cannot be run by constantly throwing blame and suspicion on industry.
"You need a helpful, cooperative atmosphere. At the same point, when you have high level, high profile probe what you need to do is to move things quickly to be transparent and where the government is concerned, come clean. I think we have done that in this case brilliantly," he said.
When asked about the fear and apprehensions the present day bureaucrats might have that they may get questioned after many years of the decisions taken, Mr Ahluwalia said, "That danger is certainly there" and "we need to resolve that in a systemic manner".
He also suggested that bureaucrats approach the Cabinet Committee on Investments (CCI) for taking "political endorsement" if they are not sure of right decision on a matter, adding that they need to give 3-4 options to the CCI for deciding the matter.
Essential Business Intelligence, Sharp Market Insights, Practical Personal Finance Advice, Daily Fuel, Gold and Silver Prices, Watch Business News Live and Latest Stories — On NDTV Profit.