Silver ETFs Are Soaring — How Much Exposure Is Too Much For Investors?

Silver's white-hot rally has pushed Indian ETFs into overdrive, reigniting the debate on whether investors should chase momentum or step back and reassess risk.

The precious metal has surged close to the psychological $100 mark, a level that market participants say could either open the door for a sharp extension towards $110–$120 or trigger violent profit booking if momentum falters. Reflecting the frenzy, Tata Silver ETF jumped 17%, while Nippon India Silver ETF, DSP Silver ETF and ICICI Prudential Silver ETF rallied around 10–11% each.

In global markets, gold and silver hit fresh record highs on Thursday, breaching $4,900 and $99, respectively, after recovering from heavy profit booking in the previous session. The rebound has been underpinned by persistent geopolitical risks, a weaker US dollar and expectations of US Federal Reserve rate cuts. In India, MCX March silver futures were trading about 2.2% higher at Rs 3,34,600 per kg.

The rally, however, is unfolding amid mixed signals from the broader commodities complex. Kotak Securities noted that base metals posted a mixed performance, with copper easing to around $12,755 per tonne after its record run, even as aluminium and zinc edged higher. The brokerage pointed to early signs of demand fatigue in China, visible in a sharp drop in the Yangshan import premium, alongside easing inventory tightness due to fresh inflows into LME warehouses. That said, Kotak said downside remains contained as supply risks persist, including a labour strike at a Chilean mine, while a softer dollar and elevated geopolitical uncertainty continue to support metals.

So, should investors buy silver ETFs now?

Market experts urge caution. Ravi Singh, Chief Research Officer at Master Capital Services, believes the current phase calls for restraint rather than aggressive positioning.

He advises investors to avoid opening large positions in gold and silver, citing elevated volatility and steep price swings. “The possibility of moving down is also raised by the volatile nature of markets,” Singh said, adding that it may be prudent to wait for a more stable and tangible trend before increasing exposure.

Instead of lump-sum bets, Singh recommends a systematic investment approach, particularly through monthly SIPs in gold funds, which allow cost averaging—buying more units during dips and fewer during rallies—thereby reducing market-timing risk. The same philosophy, he suggests, can be applied to silver exposure as well.

Portfolio strategy: hedge, not hero trade

From a portfolio-allocation standpoint, experts stress that precious metals should not be viewed as return-generating assets, but rather as tools for risk management and diversification. While gold and silver can provide protection during inflationary phases, rupee depreciation and geopolitical stress, their high volatility warrants moderation.

Investors are advised to limit precious metal exposure to a small portion of the overall portfolio, avoid over-concentration at elevated price levels, and focus on frequent rebalancing to manage risk. The emphasis, experts say, should remain on capital preservation and balance, using silver and gold as hedges and stabilisers, not short-term trading opportunities.

Silver ETFs are riding a powerful global macro wave, but with prices hovering near critical psychological levels, the risk-reward has become increasingly asymmetric. While long-term investors may consider measured, staggered exposure, chasing sharp rallies could expose portfolios to abrupt reversals. For now, discipline, moderation and diversification remain the dominant themes as investors navigate silver's scorching run.

Read More: Gold Rises Toward $5,000 As Weaker Dollar Adds Impetus To Rally

Watch LIVE TV, Get Stock Market Updates, Top Business, IPO and Latest News on NDTV Profit.