Facebook IPO: Will Morgan Stanley's big bet not pay off?

Lead Facebook Inc underwriter Morgan Stanley took a bet earlier this week when it increased the size of the social networking firm's $16 billion initial public offering and it boosted the price..Thanks to massive hype surrounding Facebook's historic public offering, the wager looked safe. But a rocky first day of trading has raised questions about whether it paid off..After a delayed start to trading, Facebook's shares spent much of the day struggling to stay above the $38 IPO price - and ended with just a 23-cent gain..As a result, Morgan Stanley may have spent billions of dollars to support the stock price by buying shares in the market. Some market participants said that the underwriters had to absorb mountains of stock to defend the $38 level and keep the market from dipping below it..The firm did this by tapping into a 63 million share over-allotment option, or greenshoe, according to sources familiar with the deal..As an indication of the cost, had Morgan Stanley bought all of the shares traded around $38 in the final 20 minutes of the day, it would have spent nearly $2 billion. Underwriters are not obligated to prop up a stock on debut, but typically do..Morgan Stanley declined to comment. The debut marks a rare stumble for a high-profile IPO. Facebook is the only recent US internet listing not to enjoy a large price jump on its first day of trading. LinkedIn, Groupon and Pandora Media all saw significant gains at their public debuts..The debut also underscores Morgan Stanley's go-it-alone handling of the offering process. Though 32 other underwriters signed on to the deal, Morgan Stanley retained tight control over information, decisions and allocations of shares, according to other underwriters..To be sure, Morgan Stanley's strong approach may have been crucial to managing such a large, high-profile offering with so many underwriters. And the fact that the stock didn't soar on its first day means they achieved full value for their client..Some issues were beyond Morgan Stanley's control. Glitches at the Nasdaq stock exchange delayed the start of trading by 45 minutes, and throughout the day many investors did not receive confirmations that their orders had been completed, brokers at Morgan Stanley, Raymond James & Associates and others said. That uncertainty about their positions may have prompted some investors to sell, worsening the downward pressure on the stock..Nasdaq posted a notice late in the day saying that orders entered for the stock before trading started "resulted in nothing being done" and offering to match orders if customers send in requests by Monday. Sources said the exchange was working through the weekend to deal with the botched trades..Facebook also altered its guidance for research earnings last week, during the road show, a rare and disruptive move..Copyright @Thomson Reuters 2012

Facebook IPO: Will Morgan Stanley's big bet not pay off?

From economic analysis to soft trend stories, here are our top 10 picks.

NDTV Profit

NDTV Profit

Follow Us

DISCOVER US FASTER

DOWNLOAD THE APP