Is The Tax Department Unduly Rewarding Its Own To Achieve Revenue Targets?

Three recent instructions by the Central Board of Direct Taxes to its tax officers have perturbed tax practitioners and their clients - tax payers. In essence, the department has offered incentives to Commissioners of Income Tax (Appeals) to decide cases against taxpayers. Or so claim the Chartered Accountant Associations of Mumbai, Ahmedabad, Surat, Karnataka and Lucknow that have written to the finance ministry against the CBDT diktat.

The Role Of CIT (Appeals)?

It's the first authority before which taxpayers, aggrieved by an order of an assessing officer, can go. There are 60 commissioners of appeals in Mumbai alone.

The commissioner of appeals can confirm, reduce, enhance or annul the assessment, as per the explanation on the tax department's website. CBDT Chairman Sushil Chandra reiterated this view to BloombergQuint.

CIT (Appeals) has the got the same powers as the assessing officer. So, if he finds that something has been left out by the income-tax officer, which was required to be added, he has the power to add it. 
Sushil Chandra, Chairman, CBDT

Tax practitioners disagree with this view.

The Supreme Court has considered this issue on various occasions and laid down that CIT (Appeals) has no power to look for new sources of income, Gautam Nayak, tax partner at CNK & Associates, said to BloombergQuint.

He can enhance the tax demand only on the issues which are subject matter of the assessing officer's order, Nayak emphasised.

Nayak is also co-chairman of the Direct Taxes Committee of the Indian Merchants Chamber. The IMC has participated in the representation made by chartered accountants' groups to the finance ministry.

Unlock this article for free
Sign up to access exclusive stories, fewer ads, and a personalised experience.
Set as Trusted Source
on Google Search