Friday Drama: Supreme Court Questions Need To File Two Petitions In Same Matter

Friday Drama: Supreme Court Questions Need To File Two Petitions In Same Matter
Supreme Court of India (Image: Supreme Court website)

The Supreme Court today said “everybody is doubting the court” after the events of last week that made a five-judge Constitution bench overturn an order saying that the Chief Justice of India only had the sole prerogative to allocate matters.

A three-judge bench led by Arun Mishra, which reserved its order today, will pronounce its judgement at 2 pm tomorrow. The bench asked petitioner Kamini Jaiswal's lawyers Shanti Bhushan and Prashant Bhushan on the need to file a petition seeking a court-monitored probe into allegations of bribes sought to influence cases when a similar plea was pending before another bench. That petition was filed by the Campaign for Judicial Accountability & Judicial Reforms before the bench of Justice AK Sikri.

The court also asked whether Prashant Bhushan's arguments make him liable for contempt proceedings. Attorney General KK Venugopal, who appeared in his personal capacity, said the petitioners must withdraw their case.

Also Read: Supreme Court Overturns Own Order Saying Chief Justice Is The ‘Master Of The Court'

Shanti Bhushan argued that though the FIR registered by the Central Bureau of Investigation doesn't name any sitting judge, it alleged that bribes were sought to influence the outcome of the case about a medical college. That case was being heard in the apex court by a bench headed by the chief justice, he said.

The petitioners had to file another plea and mention it in front of Justice Chelameswar because the first one was listed before Justice Sikri through an administrative order passed by the chief justice. He should not have been involved in the case through a judicial or an administrative order, Bhushan said.

The lawyers justified the order passed by Justice Chelameswar's bench on Thursday to set up a five-judge bench.That order was overturned by the Constitutional bench headed by the chief justice on Friday.

“It was within his powers vested by Article 142 that Justice Chelemeswar passed those orders and there is nothing wrong in it,” Bhushan said. “The order only said that the matter must be heard by five senior-most judges of this court. Why was heaven and earth moved to undermine that order?” he asked.

Unlock this article for free
Sign up to access exclusive stories, fewer ads, and a personalised experience.
Set as Trusted Source
on Google Search