Trump to Executive Branch: Don't Worry About Puerto Rico

(Bloomberg View) -- Almost three weeks since Hurricane Maria struck Puerto Rico, the island is in terrible shape. Most people do not have electricity. Almost half do not have access to safe water. Dozens of Americans have perished. By any measure, this is an extraordinary tragedy for the nation. And yet, Trump instead has constantly signaled business-as-usual. 

Is it clear that the federal government is making a serious commitment to the relief effort? Absolutely. Do we know all of what Trump is doing behind the scenes? No, although early reports were not promising. But what the president says in public is important as well.

The executive branch bureaucracy is large and unwieldy, and will not automatically shift to do anything a president might want it to do -- there are thousands of routine tasks to be completed, and all sorts of competing priorities to attend to. If presidents want the government to turn to a single purpose, they need to send clear, consistent signals that what they want to happen is now the highest immediate priority. That is simply not happening:

  • The weekend after Maria was when Trump kicked off his war on the NFL; ever since, he's demonstrated much more public interest in taking on protesting football players than in helping recovery in Puerto Rico. 
  • Golf. I'm normally very hesitant to attack presidents for "vacations" or indulging in some golf. The office follows presidents wherever they go, and everyone needs exercise and even a little down time. But for Trump to keep up his vigorous schedule of golf outings over the last three weekends (and again today) is a statement that everything is normal -- a statement that everyone in the bureaucracy can hear.
  • He's consistently downplayed the damage to Puerto Rico, saying among other things that it wasn't a "real catastrophe like Katrina." 
  • He's also blamed Puerto Ricans: feuding with the mayor of San Juan, repeating false rumors about local truck drivers, and generally treating the people as responsible for their troubles. 
  • In fact he's even mocked the local accent.
  • After personally donating $1 million to Hurricane Harvey relief, Trump hasn't made any public donation for Puerto Rico.
  • He also hasn't used his Twitter account, which he considers one of his most powerful tools, to publicize support for other relief funds; nor has he thanked the five former presidents who are spearheading charity efforts.
  • He's allowed the Jones Act waiver to expire without plans to extend it, according to Reuters. 
  • He has, however, repeatedly bragged about his own role and whined about how unappreciated he is -- not exactly a message likely to stir others to action.
  • Meanwhile, Trump still has not nominated anyone for the vacant Secretary of Homeland Security position, some 10 weeks after John Kelly moved to White House chief of staff. 

It all combines to send a strong message to the executive branch that there's nothing particularly extraordinary about the effort in Puerto Rico.

Of course, people at FEMA, in the military, and with the other agencies involved are for the most part serious professionals, and they will try their best whatever the president says. And it's impossible to connect any specific failure of this type by the president with any specific failure on the ground. 

Overall, however, it's the president's job to push the bureaucracy in the direction of pressing priorities, and Trump -- at least publicly -- just isn't doing his job, and that's beyond how he's mostly abdicated his head of state responsibilities of comforting those who need comforting.

If we look at it less as a question of specific links to specific actions and more as a question of tendencies, we can say that the more he focuses the government on solving a problem, the better job it will do -- and at least from what we know so far, he's doing a terrible job of it. Everyone can hope that relief efforts will mostly succeed despite presidential failure, but that's a pretty tenuous way to run a government. 

This column does not necessarily reflect the opinion of the editorial board or Bloomberg LP and its owners.

Jonathan Bernstein is a Bloomberg View columnist. He taught political science at the University of Texas at San Antonio and DePauw University and wrote A Plain Blog About Politics.

  1. For that matter, he's also sending the message that the previous hurricanes in Texas and Florida are ancient history, rather than a continued priority as recovery continues.

To contact the author of this story: Jonathan Bernstein at jbernstein62@bloomberg.net.

To contact the editor responsible for this story: Mike Nizza at mnizza3@bloomberg.net.

For more columns from Bloomberg View, visit http://www.bloomberg.com/view.

Unlock this article for free
Sign up to access exclusive stories, fewer ads, and a personalised experience.
Set as Trusted Source
on Google Search