Tesla’s New Chair Is Part of the Furniture
(Bloomberg Opinion) -- There was a touch of humor in Tesla Inc.'s announcement of a new board chair, and it involved Elon Musk on Twitter, of course. Replying to the company's own account, the CEO and former chair expressed his excitement about his replacement in the role, Robyn Denholm:
All of which is great, except Denholm isn't “joining.” She's been on Tesla's board for four years and, one presumes, has been working together with Musk already.
Joking and tenses aside, this isn't an optimal outcome.
That isn't a comment on Denholm's career. She has a wealth of senior experience at firms including Australian telco Telstra Corp Ltd., where she was recently appointed chief of finance and strategy, and Juniper Networks, where she was chief of finance and operations. She is, strikingly, leaving Telstra in order to focus on her new role (pending a six-month notice period).
The issue, as Musk's tweet unintentionally highlighted, is that Denholm has been on the board of Tesla for almost half its life as a public company. This is problematic for two reasons.
The first is that it represents a missed opportunity. Recall that Musk must give up his seat at the head of table in order to settle with the Securities and Exchange Commission, which had accused him of misleading shareholders with his half-baked take-private tweets in August. The broad thrust of that settlement was to fix the lack of effective governance and oversight the bizarre episode exemplified. Besides separating the CEO and chair roles for at least three years, Tesla agreed, among other things, to appoint two new independent directors and institute better controls on the company's external communication, including Musk's own.
This gave Tesla a chance to appoint someone from outside the company, preferably someone with extensive experience in automotive manufacturing, and definitely someone who hadn't worked with Musk before. According to Tesla's proxy statement, Denholm has some prior experience in finance roles at Toyota Motor Corp. But the real issue is that Tesla settled on an insider when an outsider would have signaled real change.
The second problem is that, as an insider, Denholm has already supposedly been providing independent oversight during some of the most unsettling periods in Tesla's history; precisely those periods when that oversight seemed — how to put this? — intensely subtle from an outside perspective.
She was, of course, part of the special committee assembled and then disassembled during that whirlwind 17-day take-private whatever-it-was. Denholm was also part of the board that didn't manage to rein in Musk's increasingly bizarre Twitter habits — which, in hindsight, look like a prelude to the now infamous “funding secured” missive of August 7. As part of the compensation committee, she also had a role in setting Musk's gargantuan new pay package earlier this year (which was approved by shareholders after two large proxy-advisory firms gave it a thumbs down). On that front, having received total compensation of almost $5 million in 2017 (virtually all of it in stock options), Denholm was the highest-paid member of a board whose compensation stands far above their peers at similar firms and sits at odds with its apparent usefulness.
Denholm was also, of course, part of the board that approved Tesla's takeover of SolarCity Corp. in 2016. This deal, which almost doubled Tesla's debt, was referred to by one proxy-advisory firm as a “thinly veiled bailout plan” for a struggling company where Musk was a major shareholder and chairman and the CEO was his cousin. I was reminded of this in Tesla's latest quarterly SEC filing. This disclosed that, in August, Tesla cashed out Musk and SolarCity's former chief technology officer (another cousin) on $82.5 million of promissory notes that were effectively old “Solar Bonds” they had bought from SolarCity shortly after the acquisition was announced.
None of this means Denholm can't somehow assume a more forceful position as chair and inject some accountability into Tesla's governance. It just means we haven't seen much evidence of it thus far. Which rather undermines the whole point of this appointment in the first place.
To contact the editor responsible for this story: Mark Gongloff at mgongloff1@bloomberg.net
This column does not necessarily reflect the opinion of the editorial board or Bloomberg LP and its owners.
Liam Denning is a Bloomberg Opinion columnist covering energy, mining and commodities. He previously was editor of the Wall Street Journal's Heard on the Street column and wrote for the Financial Times' Lex column. He was also an investment banker.
©2018 Bloomberg L.P.
-
We May Need Another Tukaram Mundhe To Fight Air Pollution | The Reason Why
Developers may install basic measures such as sprinklers and green nets, resume work, and continue violating rules when this equipment stops working.
-
Extracting Value From Battery Scrap Could Be Challenging For India | The Reason Why
A discarded lithium-ion battery still contains valuable materials such as lithium, nickel and cobalt. These can be recovered and reused. When such batteries are crushed and shredded, they produce a dark powder called black mass.
-
One El Nino, India Can Handle. Two Could Break The Granary
India's grain stocks can absorb one bad year, but a second El Nino could drain the buffer in two to three years, economists say.
-
India's Troika Of Good Luck | Joining The Dots
As Jensen Huang's exit drags Nvidia down, a cooling AI trade and resilient earnings have revived investor interest in India. A likely RBI rate hike looms.
-
Talking Points This Week: Leadership Shock At Nvidia, Earnings Strength, And The Fog Over Hormuz
The Anthropic IPO pricing and first trading day, Nvidia's upcoming earnings, and any fresh signals from Iran will set the tone for the following week.
-
Signature Play: The Classic Cocktail Is Dead. Or Is It?
Classic cocktails are disappearing from India's cocktail menus. But they're still being ordered, taught to bartenders and borrowed from. So, who's really having the last drink?
-
A New Samvat Wishlist: Inclusive Prosperity And Human Development
India has strengthened its economic foundations through infrastructure, digital access and enterprise. Its next growth chapter must deepen productivity, create better livelihoods and widen participation in prosperity.
-
Love, Sex Aur Dhokha: The Audacious Plot To Spy On Jensen Huang
A Taipei dinner, a Singapore chip buyer and a suspected Chinese asset: inside the alleged spy operation that got close to NVIDIA's Jensen Huang.
-
Ten Things I Learnt This Samvat
Patience can be a trap. Cheap stocks can stay cheap. Leverage can wipe you out. What did Samvat 2082 teach us? Niraj Shah writes on 10 lessons from the year gone by.
-
Talking Points This Week: Tech Nerves, FII Buying, And A Faraway Banking Shock
The global markets are not shining this Diwali. The exception in the large markets is, India.