Cyrus Mistry Rakes Up Ratan Tata’s Compensation, Slams ‘Questionable’ Decisions 

Cyrus Mistry Rakes Up Ratan Tata’s Compensation, Slams ‘Questionable’ Decisions 
Ousted Tata Sons Chairman, Cyrus Mistry arrives for the Tata Chemicals board meeting at Bombay House in Mumbai on Thursday. (Photographer: Mitesh Bhuvad/PTI)

A media statement issued by Cyrus Mistry's office throws light on why expenses at Tata Sons have increased over the last two years.

Mistry's statement is in response to an allegation made by Tata Sons, in a public statement issued on November 10, that staff and other expenses at Tata Sons had increased from Rs 304 crore in 2012-13 to Rs 470 crore in 2015.

The statement attributes the increase in expenses to

  • Earlier Ratan Tata & senior group members worked in non-executive roles and drew commissions from Tata Sons not compensation as did Mistry and team.
  • Mistry added a few senior positions such as Group CTO and Group Strategy Head
  • Nira Radia (Vaishnavi Communication) was paid approximately Rs 40 crore per year. Ratan Tata then brought in Arun Nanda (Rediffusion Edelman) at Rs 60 crore per year.
  • Entire office costs of Chairman Emeritus, Ratan Tata, totaling approximately Rs 30 crore in 2015. A significant amount of which was for the use of corporate jets.

Mistry's office also claimed that impairments and writedowns at Tata Sons during his tenure were due to legacy issues, largely relating to Tata Teleservices Ltd. Mistry took decisions “in keeping with Tata values” and significantly strengthened Tata Sons' ability to absorb future shocks, the statement added.

Here's a full reproduction of the statement from Mistry's Office.

The Tata Sons full-page newspaper advertisement on 11 November vaguely accused that expenses and impairments increased at Tata Sons during Cyrus Mistry's chairmanship. Insinuating the increase in expenses as a failure of Mr Mistry is another brazen attempt to mislead the public and shareholders.

Since the issue has been raked up to get a “desired perspective” despite the facts having been privately communicated to Tata Trusts as early as January, the record is being set right through this statement.

Also Read: Tata Motors' Independent Directors Play It Neutral But The Subtext Says It All

First, it is important to appreciate some fundamental changes between the last five years of Mr Ratan Tata's tenure and the period under Mr Mistry's leadership. In the five years preceding 2012, several group centre (GCC) members held what were deemed “non-executive” roles in Tata Sons. As such, they, including Mr Tata, drew their compensation as commissions from Tata Sons instead of salaries which skews base year comparisons. It is also public knowledge that several erstwhile directors of Tata Sons drew additional parallel commissions from operating group companies.

The group centre (GEC), reporting to Mr Mistry, drew remuneration only from Tata Sons. No member including Mr Mistry took any commissions from any of the operating group companies. This arrangement was a cleaner and more transparent system to ensure that those involved in running the group were remunerated only by the group's core investment company and not by the operating companies.

Second, Mr Mistry added a few senior positions such as Group CTO and Group Strategy Head. These positions were aimed at enhancing the group central capabilities to future-proof the group. The Group CTO Office works on technology projects relating to multiple group companies. Promising results are emerging in areas such as Graphene, Renewables, Fleet Analytics and Industrial Wearables. This focus on technology will be a differentiator for the Tata Group, and pay dividends in the years ahead.

Third, another significant difference was due to the cessation of services by Ms Nira Radia (Vaishnavi Communication) who was being paid approximately Rs 40 crore per year. She had been replaced by Mr Arun Nanda (Rediffusion Edelman) who had been brought in by Mr Ratan Tata at a cost of Rs 60 crore per year for PR support just prior to Mr Mistry taking charge. It is worth noting that a part of this PR infrastructure was also provided to the Tata Trusts, while paid for by Tata Sons.

Finally, the Tata Sons full-page ad of November 10 fails to acknowledge that Tata Sons was also bearing the entire office costs of the Chairman Emeritus, Mr Ratan Tata. This figure was about Rs 30 crore in 2015. A significant amount of which was for the use of corporate jets. This dual structure and attendant costs did not exist earlier.

Also Read: Tata Group Episode: Toe The Promoter Line, Or You Will Be Shown The Door?

Mr Mistry did not approach any of the businesses with a view to do a quick cleansing so that he could immediately demonstrate decent results going forward.

The efforts of Tata Sons, under his leadership has always been to look at Strategy, Structure and Leadership changes to drive operational improvements before examining Mergers, Exits or Shutdowns. All the decisions taken in this regard were in keeping with the Tata values and with the full consent of the Board. The way forward on this front was documented in the board meeting minutes as well as the 2025 Group Strategy Document, which was presented to the Tata Sons at board meetings held as early as June 2015 then in, December 2015, and further iterated in June 2016.

The impairments and write downs at Tata Sons were due to legacy issues, largely relating to TTSL. There were also other investments of questionable nature such as Nagarjuna refineries (Rs 400 crore) and SASOL JV. One investment in Piaggio Aero, a company in the aerospace sector with a friend of Mr Tata, was especially distressing. Tata Sons decided to exit the company at a commercial loss of Rs 1,150 crore. This was after the efforts of Mr Bharat Vasani and Mr Farokh Subedar who managed to recover Rs 1,500 crore, overcoming the objections of Mr Ratan Tata who in contrast favoured increasing investments in that company. Today, the company is, for all practical purposes, nearly bankrupt.

The challenges the Group faced could not be wished away. Each problem had to be dealt with a view to creating the most palatable solution for all stakeholders, while simultaneously trying to ensure that the situation did not deteriorate. Mr Mistry focussed on ensuring that Tata Sons built its reserves and resources to handle the necessary writedowns as the portfolio restructured. Between FY11 to FY15, Tata Sons networth, after considering impairments increased from Rs 26,000 crore to Rs 42,000 crore, significantly strengthening the ability to absorb future shocks.

Also Read: War On Black Money Or Peace With Magenta Money?

Unlock this article for free
Sign up to access exclusive stories, fewer ads, and a personalised experience.
Set as Trusted Source
on Google Search