Cyrus Mistry Hits Back After Tatas' Criticism Of Independent Directors

Cyrus Mistry Hits Back After Tatas' Criticism Of Independent Directors
Independent directors at Tata Chemicals have backed Cyrus Mistry, the ousted chairman of Tata Sons.

Mumbai: Terming Tata Sons' contention that group companies were "drifting away" under him as "furthest from truth", the ousted chairman Cyrus Mistry on Sunday hit back at Tata Sons calling its criticism of independent directors as "truly unfortunate".

"To suggest that 'ulterior objectives' and 'clever strategy' can sway these eminent names in undertaking their fiduciary duties and discharging the duties mandated by the statute as independent directors is absolutely astonishing and really speaks to how low Tata Sons has unfortunately stooped in their public statements," a statement from his office said, in a rebuttal to the recent actions of Tata Sons.

Stating that the independent directors whose conduct has been questioned include names like Deepak Parekh, Nusli Wadia and Nadir Godrej, among others, Mr Mistry added that it is "truly unfortunate" that independence of "stalwarts of India Inc" is being questioned.

The statement is a rebuttal to a nine-page open letter issued by Tata Sons in which it had accused Mr Mistry of "trying to gain control of Indian Hotels Company, whose independent directors had sided with the former chairman of Tata Sons". (Read: 'Mistry betrayed trust': Tatas in 9-page letter explaining his ouster)

"He (Mistry) has cleverly ensured over these years that he would be the only Tata Sons representative on the board of IHCL in order to frustrate Tata Sons' ability to exercise influence and control on IHCL," the Tata Sons letter had said.

Independent directors at Tata Chemicals have also backed Mr Mistry, which has led Tata Sons to initiate action to expel Mr Wadia from its company boards. (Read: Tatas now gun for Wadia, who backed Mistry at board meeting)

In its letter, Tata Sons had also alleged that Mr Mistry was trying to gain control of the group's main companies and regretted its decision to appoint him as chairman four years ago.

It had said the structure of the group has been "consciously dismantled so that now the operating companies are drifting farther away from the promoter company and their major shareholder".

Mr Mistry retorted back at this on Sunday, saying these suggestions are "furthest from the truth" and added that changing the board structure was part of a plan to alter the corporate governance practices with an aim to make the salt-to-software group's companies run independently.

"The corporate governance framework that was developed under Mistry's leadership attempted to ensure group companies would adhere to the group values, share best practices, enable movement of talent, exploit win-win synergies, and do all of this without impinging on the independence of the operating companies and the boards that they are ultimately responsible to," he said.

This was done to protect the interests of all stakeholders, employees, and minority shareholders, he said, adding that it was a case of placing responsibility "where it should lie".

Mr Mistry's statement also made a veiled but not fully elaborate reference to insider trading while explaining the need to have a new corporate governance framework.

Unlock this article for free
Sign up to access exclusive stories, fewer ads, and a personalised experience.
Set as Trusted Source
on Google Search