India Picks Fiscal Conservatism Over Growth Boost in Budget

Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman has stuck to a plan to narrow the fiscal deficit over time by keeping spending in check.

India Picks Fiscal Conservatism Over Growth Boost in Budget
Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman. (Photographer: T. Narayan/Bloomberg)

(Bloomberg) -- India’s new finance minister resisted calls for a fiscal boost to spur a weakening economy, sticking instead to a plan to narrow the budget deficit over time by keeping spending in check.

The fiscal gap target for the year that began on April 1 was lowered to 3.3% of gross domestic product from 3.4% set in February’s interim plan, Nirmala Sitharaman said in her maiden budget in Parliament in New Delhi on Friday. The deficit is forecast to come down even further to 3% of GDP by March 2021, according to the Finance Ministry.

India Picks Fiscal Conservatism Over Growth Boost in Budget

Sitharaman, 59, will be relying on an ambitious revenue target to narrow the deficit as the government reins in spending: she plans to increase taxes on the wealthy, raise duties on gold and gasoline, extract higher dividends from the central bank and boost income from asset sales. On the expenditure side, $11 billion was set aside for farmer support and nearly as much for a capital boost to banks.

Sitharaman told reporters on Saturday that India is confident that its tax and disinvestment projections are realistic. She said raising duties on a few items isn’t protectionist and that boosting tax rates on the rich isn’t punishment.

Her budget drew applause from bond and currency investors, but left credit rating companies with mixed feelings and stock traders with losses. Yields on India’s benchmark 10-year bonds dropped 8 basis points to 6.67%, while the benchmark equity index closed 1% lower, the first drop in five days.

India Picks Fiscal Conservatism Over Growth Boost in Budget

The absence of any substantial fiscal stimulus puts the ball back in the central bank’s court to spur growth. The Reserve Bank of India has already cut interest rates three times this year and signaled more easing to come as the global economy continues to weaken.

Achieving the competing goals of a lower fiscal deficit and faster growth will be “very challenging,” said Gene Fang, associate managing director at Moody’s Investor Services in Singapore. “We expect the economy to grow relatively slowly.”

Under Pressure

That won’t be good news for Prime Minister Narendra Modi, who returned to office in May following a landslide election victory. He’s under pressure to revive growth after it slipped to a five-year low of 5.8% in the three months to March. High frequency data show a sustained recovery is still distant, given a gloomy global outlook exacerbated by U.S.-China trade tensions.

What Bloomberg Economists Say

“The first budget of Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s 2.0 government renewed its commitment to fiscal discipline, which bodes well for lower interest rates. The budget’s rigor should help support a V-shaped economic recovery.”

-- Abhishek Gupta, India economist

Sitharaman, who is known to be fiscally conservative, focused her budget on plans to unclog infrastructure bottlenecks and revive investments.

She promised to recapitalize weak state-run banks by 700 billion rupees and announced a package for the stricken shadow-banking sector. The debt-related woes among non-banking finance companies have been one of the prime reasons for a slowdown in consumption, which contributes nearly 60% to the nation’s GDP.

India Picks Fiscal Conservatism Over Growth Boost in Budget

Sitharaman proposed steps to deepen infrastructure financing in the country and measures to boost foreign participation in the corporate debt market. She said the nation needs 20 trillion rupees annual investment on infrastructure, and the government will be tapping the overseas bond market for funds for the first time ever.

“The budget, by itself, is unlikely to spur growth significantly,” said Priyanka Kishore, head of India and Southeast Asia economics at Oxford Economics in Singapore. “But continued focus on infrastructure spending and measures like recapitalization of banks and a package of the shadow banking sector should create a positive environment for reviving private investment.”

The Finance Ministry on Wednesday said growth will probably reach 7% in the current fiscal year, pinning its hopes on greater political stability to spur investments. That forecast matches the RBI’s projection and is higher than last year’s expansion of 6.8%.

For now, though, the attention will shift to the central bank to provide support to the economy.

“The government’s commitment to fiscal consolidation gives the RBI more leeway to ease in the coming months,” Kishore said.

--With assistance from Vrishti Beniwal, Ronojoy Mazumdar and Shruti Srivastava.

To contact the reporter on this story: Anirban Nag in Mumbai at

To contact the editors responsible for this story: Nasreen Seria at, Karthikeyan Sundaram

©2019 Bloomberg L.P.