Bofors Pales Into Insignificance Before Rafale ‘Scam’, Allege Yaswant Sinha, Arun Shourie

Yashwant Sinha, Arun Shourie and Prashant Bhushan team up to question the terms of the Rafale jet deal.

 Visitors look at a Dassault Aviation Rafale Omnirole fighter jet. (Photographer: Antoine Antoniol/Bloomberg News)
Visitors look at a Dassault Aviation Rafale Omnirole fighter jet. (Photographer: Antoine Antoniol/Bloomberg News)

The Rafale deal is a case of "monumental criminal misconduct" by the NDA government and the scam involving it is much bigger than the Bofors scandal, former Union ministers Yashwant Sinha and Arun Shourie alleged, demanding a time-bound probe into the contract by national auditor Comptroller and Auditor General.

Sinha and Shourie, addressing a press conference along with lawyer-activist Prashant Bhushan, raised a number of questions over the Rs 58,000 crore deal for procurement of 36 Rafale fighter jets from France.

The trio, known to be critical of the ruling government, also accused Prime Minister Narendra Modi of single-handedly changing the parameters of the deal and alleged there were gross violations committed in following mandatory procedures before finalising the contract.

The entire deal was a “textbook case of criminal misconduct, of misuse of public office and of enriching parties at the expense of the national interest and national security”, they alleged, adding there was an effort by the government to “conceal” facts.

The Congress has been alleging massive irregularities in the deal, and that the BJP government is procuring each aircraft at a cost of over Rs 1,670 crore as against the Rs 526 crore price finalised by the UPA government for the procurement of 126 Rafale jets. The deal negotiated by the UPA could not be inked.

The trio also rejected government's contention that the prices of the aircraft have gone up due to India-specific add-ons and weapons systems, citing a joint statement by India and France during Prime Minister Modi's visit to Paris in 2015.

They said the joint statement mentioned that the aircraft and the associated systems and weapons would be delivered to India on the same configuration as had been tested and approved by the Indian Air Force for the deal negotiated for procurement of 126 jets under the UPA government.

Shourie alleged that there had been "gross misuse of office" by which the original project for the acquisition of 126 fighter aircraft had been "sabotaged".

I can tell you, as a person who handled the matter with regards to Bofors, that Bofors was absolutely nothing compared to this (Rafale scam). There was never a sudden change (in the deal) like this in which you suddenly give up the entire project.
Arun Shourie, Former Minister (Atal Bihari Vajpayee government)

The Congress has also been pressing for price details of the deal but the NDA government has refused to divulge them citing confidentiality provisions of a 2008 Indo-France pact. The government has asserted that there were no irregularities in the deal.

"I would suggest, on our behalf, that the audit which Comptroller and Auditor General was supposed to take up, that should be a forensic audit and it should be completed within three months," said Sinha, adding "It is a huge scam. Bofors pales into insignificance before this scam."

The Bofors scandal, involving procurement of howitzer guns in the late 1980s, had rocked the then Rajiv Gandhi government.

Terming the Rafale deal as the "biggest defence scam" that this country has seen so far, Bhushan alleged that it involved a loss of at least Rs 35,000 crore to the public exchequer.

The trio said the ever-shifting statements of the minister of defence, invoking of secrecy clauses in the contract and the inexplicable dropping of government-owned Hindustan Aeronautics Ltd. from the project were among the factors which convinced them that the deal was a major scandal.

"We hope that the opposition parties will relentlessly pursue this matter, the way the BJP had pursued Bofors at that time. With the same tenacity, the opposition parties must pursue the matter," said Shourie.

Congress Vs BJP On Rafale Deal: Four Key Questions Answered

The three leaders also alleged the deal benefits private-sector company Reliance Defence and Aerospace, saying that the company, which was under Rs 8,000 crore in debt and had no experience in making aircraft, was involved under mandatory offset obligations of the French firm.

Reliance Defence Chief Executive Officer Rajesh Dhingra rejected the charges and said no contract related to the Rafale deal was awarded to the company by Defence Ministry.

"As all 36 aircraft are to be delivered 'fly-away', to be manufactured in France by Dassault and exported to India, how is the question of experience in manufacturing aircraft relevant here," he asked.

Foreign defence entities are mandated to spend at least 30 percent of the total contract value in India through procurement of components or setting up of research and development facilities under India's defence offset policy.

Rafale Jet Deal: France Says It Inked Pact With India To Protect Classified Information