In a ruling that closes a nearly two-decade-long legal battle, the Madras High Court has directed filmmaker Gautham Vasudev Menon and his production house Photon Factory to repay Rs 4.25 crore along with 12% interest to RS Infotainment.
The order came on March 23, 2026, when a division bench of Justices P Velmurugan and K Govindarajan Thilakavadi dismissed Menon's appeal against a 2022 judgment. Upholding the earlier ruling, the court observed, “We are of the considered view that there is no infirmity found in the judgment and decree passed by the learned Single Judge, warrants any interference by this Court.”
What Triggered The Case
The dispute dates back to a 2008 agreement between Menon's Photon Factory and RS Infotainment, headed by producer S. Elred Kumar. The two parties had planned a Tamil film, referred to as Production no. 6, with a proposed budget of Rs 13.5 crore. As per the agreement, work on the film was expected to begin in December 2008 and conclude by April 2009.
Although the full funding was not released, RS Infotainment paid Rs 4.25 crore in phases to initiate the project. However, the film failed to take off, with no confirmed progress in production.
ALSO READ: 'Please Fix The Roads': Sudhaa Chandran Appeals To BMC
Claims And Counterclaims
During the proceedings, Menon argued that delays were caused due to payment-related issues and changes in the project's development. He also claimed that the film was eventually made in another form as Neethaane En Ponvasantham (2012), suggesting that the initial agreement had effectively been honoured.
The court, however, disagreed. It found that the 2012 film was produced under a separate contract signed in 2011 and was not connected to the original 2008 deal. It also noted that there was no clear evidence to show that the Rs 4.25 crore received earlier had been used for that film.
Court's Stand And Outcome
The bench highlighted the lack of proof that the original project had even begun. “The defendants have not produced any tangible and valuable evidence to prove that the film was ever commenced,” the court stated. It also pointed out that the bills and documents submitted did not establish a clear link to the agreed project.
ALSO READ: Madras High Court Receives Petition To Stay Screening Of Dhurandhar 2 Ahead Of TN Polls
With the appeal dismissed, the repayment order now stands final. Menon and his firm must return Rs 4.25 crore with 12% interest calculated from May 2010, along with litigation costs.
The ruling brings long-awaited closure to the case and reinforces the importance of accountability in film agreements.
Essential Business Intelligence, Continuous LIVE TV, Sharp Market Insights, Practical Personal Finance Advice and Latest Stories — On NDTV Profit.