An eerie silence descended upon the 132,000-seater Narendra Modi Stadium in those final, agonising overs on Feb. 22, 2026. A silence that wasn't merely a reaction to India's collapse on the pitch, but a collective chill spreading across a fanbase haunted by the ghosts of 2016, realising that for all the progress made in the build-up to a home T20 World Cup, the memories of a home-soil meltdown leave scars that aren't easily forgotten.
As India's net run rate plummeted to a staggering -3.800, the scoreboard didn't just reflect a 76-run defeat, it brought with it a Deja Vu moment of how a decade ago, an "unbeatable" Indian side was humbled by New Zealand in Nagpur in their Super 10 opener.
Ten years have passed since then, but the defeat feels hauntingly familiar.
As India are left dealing with a potentially catastrophic hit to their NRR, the question isn't just about how they lost to South Africa. It's whether they are trapped in the same "host's curse" that nearly derailed them in 2016.
The "Invincibility" Trap
Both in 2016 and 2026, India entered the home World Cup looking like a team that is nearly untouchable in the T20 format.
In 2016, Team India entered the tournament on the back of a 3-0 T20I series whitewash in Australia and also having won the Asia Cup, which had just shifted to a T20 format, without losing a single game.
Fast forward to 2026, India very recently dismantled Australia 2-1 Down Under in a T20I series in the build-up to the World Cup. Suryakumar Yadav's team also lifted the Asia Cup in September 2025 without losing a single game in the tournament.
In both eras, the sheer weight of expectation seemed to turn the team's momentum into pressure the moment the home tournament began.
The First Shock: Nagpur vs Ahmedabad
The similarities in the opening disasters in both tournaments are also quite jarring. In both instances, a pitch expected to favour the hosts became a graveyard for their ambitions.
In 2016, it was Mitchell Santner's (4/11) left-arm spin that strangled India as the hosts folded for just 79 runs in their chase of New Zealand's total of 126/7, losing by 47 runs.
On Sunday in Ahmedabad, it was Marco Jansen's (4/22) flawless execution of the Proteas bowling plans combined with the tactical discipline of Keshav Maharaj (3/24) that combined to bowl out India for just 111. Falling short by 76 runs, making it their largest T20 World Cup defeat and second biggest defeat by runs in all T20Is.
ALSO READ | India's T20 World Cup 2026 Qualification Scenario: Check How Suryakumar Yadav's Team Can Reach Semi Finals
The outcome in both tournaments remains the same. From pre-tournament favourites India are left with no margin for error and also hoping for other results to go their way.
It's entirely possible for three teams to end up on the same points within the group, and in such a scenario the negative NRR of -3.800 could definitely come back to haunt the Men in Blue.
The "Lone Warrior" Who Has Remained A Constant: Jasprit Bumrah
There is one bridge between these two eras - Jasprit Bumrah.
In 2016, a young Bumrah was the revelation of the tournament, holding his nerve in a one-run win against Bangladesh to keep India alive. Yesterday, as the Proteas plundered runs at 9.35 per over, Bumrah stood alone with figures of 3/15 and a baffling economy of just 3.75.
However, in 2016, India had a ‘Safety Net' of the highest quality in Virat Kohli, who played some iconic innings against Pakistan and Australia to drag a struggling team into the semifinals.
In 2026, with an ultra-aggressive top order that seems to lack a ‘Plan B' on slightly challenging pitches, the search for that stabiliser is becoming desperate.
Is History About to Repeat?
In 2016, India managed to scrape through to the semifinals by the skin of their teeth, only to be outclassed by a more balanced and belligerent West Indies side, who would go on to lift the trophy.
Today, India finds itself in the same 'do-or-die' scenario. To qualify for the semifinals, India doesn't just need to beat Zimbabwe and the West Indies; they need to do so by handsome margins and hope neither of those two teams manage to match India's points total, leaving qualification to the NRR fate.
However, the 2016 campaign was defined by individual brilliance of Kohli and Bumrah papering over the team's flaws. With no such ‘Safety Net' yet in the batting order, India need to find some other ways to answer the questions thrown at them or history may repeat itself with their campaign ending much sooner than what the home crowd is prepared for.
ALSO READ | T20 World Cup 2026: Have ICC Pitches Slowed Down India's Run Machine? The Numbers Say Yes
Essential Business Intelligence, Continuous LIVE TV, Sharp Market Insights, Practical Personal Finance Advice and Latest Stories — On NDTV Profit.