When it sits down for the October review, India’s Monetary Policy Committee would have completed two years since its inception in 2016.
This will help confront inflation. It will also, at the margin, help temper aggregate demand and bring down the current account deficit to a more sustainable level.Sajjid Chinoy, Chief India Economist, JPMorgan
Also Read: This Time Is (Slightly) Different, For India
Along With The Mandate....
Should the MPC choose to stick to the letter and the spirit of its mandate, it may not be in a position to address specific trouble spots in the economy and markets. That task may fall on the RBI.
Take, for instance, the tight liquidity conditions and the nervousness in credit markets. The MPC may choose to turn hawkish, drop its neutral stance and hike rates in keeping with its inflation mandate. This could add to the troubles of the non-banking sector, which would see refinancing rates rise and margins slip. The RBI may not be averse to higher rates, which would be consistent with the monetary policy stance, but it may also need to step in with liquidity support.
It will likely continue buying government bonds via its open market operations to ensure liquidity remains close to neutral or in mild-deficit mode. If the situation worsens, it may also need to consider options to ensure the smooth flow of credit to segments like NBFCs and mutual funds.
On the flip side, should the MPC take the unlikely call of keeping rates on hold, the rupee weakness may worsen and the RBI may need to step in more aggressively to support the currency. That may be in the form of larger dollar sales or an extra-ordinary measure like a special window to attract dollars from non-resident Indians.
Ananth Narayan, associate professor of finance at SP Jain Institute of Management and Research says that the starting point to address the current set of problems is hawkish monetary policy. This, however, may need to go together with the use of buffers such as forex reserves or liquidity facilities, to buy time till structural issues are corrected.
We have a financial stability problem. At a time like this, we cannot be seen to be lax or behind the curve. We cannot afford to have demand go up. We have to curtail demand through monetary and fiscal policy. In the meantime, we have buffers which we can used to buy time to fix the structural imbalances.Ananth Narayan, Associate Professor, SP Jain Institute of Management and Research
Beyond The Mandate...
While the MPC may choose to restrain its actions to fit its mandate, should it choose to weigh in on longer term structural issues? More specifically, the current account deficit.
Does the MPC see the current account deficit as a consequence of a savings-investment imbalance? If so, does it foresee the need for higher rates to correct that imbalance? Does it want to debate the export-import imbalance and move towards aggregate demand just as the investment cycle is picking up?
Chinoy believes that it can do all this through the lens of inflation and growth. “The current account imbalance is simply reflecting an imbalance that investment is higher than savings. Those imbalances also get reflected in core inflation,” said Chinoy, while adding that by tackling inflation you are also indirectly tackling the external imbalances. The MPC should stick to that approach rather than confusing the markets with different indicators.
In the midst of global uncertainty, you don’t want to add policy uncertainty....The last thing you need is going back to the confusion of the multi-indicator approach where the markets were constantly guessing what the RBI will be reacting to.Sajjid Chinoy, Chief India Economist, JPMorgan
Ananth Narayan added that the RBI and the MPC are doing a good job. They are being conservative and cautious in their approach, said Narayan. He, however, added that there is no denying the ‘impossible trinity’ between monetary policy, capital flows and the currency markets which cannot be overlooked.
Watch the discussion with Sajjid Chinoy and Ananth Narayan.
Ira Dugal is Editor - Banking, Finance & Economy at BloombergQuint.