Conversations on X about Silver Exchange Traded Funds (ETFs) have spiked as the funds trade at premiums of 8% to 18% above their net asset value (NAV). Financial planners are warning investors to hold off on buying until prices stabilise.
The premiums mean buyers are paying well above the actual value of the silver the ETFs hold. The reason is a shortage of physical silver bars, which has disrupted the usual mechanism that keeps ETF prices in line with the metal they track.
Under normal conditions, large investors perform arbitrage: they buy silver, sell ETF units, and profit from the difference, bringing prices back in line with the NAV. Currently, this process is failing. Market makers cannot obtain enough silver to exchange for ETF units, leaving prices elevated.
Deepak Shenoy of Capital Mind explained that the shortage has created a scarcity of sellers. “With low physical silver available, a market maker isn't able to do this, so there are not enough sellers in the market,” he said.
Silver ETFs at a step premium of up to 18%, be mindful.
October 9, 2025
Source - Industry colleague / WhatsApp pic.twitter.com/OCuwa95SXoSilver is apparently tough to source. The market maker of the silver etf usually buys silver in physical form, and exchanges that with the AMC for etf units, to sell units in the market.
With low physical silver available, a market maker isn't able to do this, so there are not… https://t.co/NNStRPJBdwOctober 9, 2025AdvertisementRajneesh Jha of Vitta Capital said investors should avoid chasing inflated prices. “Such imbalances don't last long — when supply normalises, ETF prices can drop sharply even if silver prices stay flat,” he added.
⚠️ Silver ETF Alert ⚠️ All Indian Silver ETFs are now trading at 8–18% above their NAV — that means you're paying more than the actual silver value!
Why?
Because there's a shortage of physical silver — ETFs can't source bars easily, so supply is tight and prices have inflated.… pic.twitter.com/f0irQoYljSOctober 9, 2025 The premium has influenced fund strategies. Kotak Mutual Fund has stopped accepting fresh lump-sum investments in its Silver ETF Fund of Fund to prevent investors from buying into overvalued units. Financial planners are urging investors to wait until premiums ease before making large purchases.
Santosh Meena, head of research at Swastika Investmart, pointed out that this decoupling of ETF prices from their NAV has become a curious pattern in India's silver market. "Silver ETFs like Nippon India and ICICI Prudential are trading at notable premiums. This is driven by low trading volumes and extremely bullish sentiment," he said.
AdvertisementWatch LIVE TV, Get Stock Market Updates, Top Business, IPO and Latest News on NDTV Profit.